At a Glance: The Verdict
| Garmin Forerunner 170 | Garmin Forerunner 55 |
|---|---|
|
Best For: New buyers who want the AMOLED screen and Garmin Pay The 2026 refresh and the default pick for anyone shopping today. You get a bright AMOLED touchscreen, contactless payments, and SpO2 at $299.99. |
Best For: Budget runners who just want reliable tracking and max battery The 2021 workhorse, now heavily discounted. Same single-band GPS as the new model and actually longer battery, for a lot less money. |
Quick Buy Path
Check today’s pricing before you go deeper.
If these are already your two finalists, compare current pricing now, then keep reading for the full verdict.
These are the same Garmin running line, five years apart. The Forerunner 170 is the 2026 release; the Forerunner 55 is the 2021 budget classic that’s now selling well below its old price.
If you’re a brand-new buyer, the 170 is the default: it’s the newer, better-equipped watch. The real question is whether its upgrades are worth $100 more, and whether the aging 55 is now too good a deal to ignore.
Key Differences
- Display: The 170 has a bright 1.2-inch AMOLED touchscreen (390 x 390). The 55 uses an older 1.04-inch transflective MIP screen (208 x 208): easy to read in sunlight, but dull and low
At a Glance: The Verdict
Garmin Forerunner 170 Garmin Forerunner 55 Best For: New buyers who want a modern AMOLED screen and tap-to-pay
The newer, pricier pick. You get a bright 1.2-inch touchscreen, Garmin Pay, blood oxygen tracking, and a barometric altimeter. But you trade away four days of battery life to get it.
Best For: Budget runners who want the longest battery and lowest price
The older, cheaper workhorse. Plainer screen and fewer sensors, but it runs 14 days between charges and nails the same core running metrics for $100 less.
Both of these are entry-level Garmin running watches, but they aren’t a coin-flip. The Forerunner 170 is the newer, more expensive model, and for a brand-new buyer it’s the default recommendation. The real question is whether its upgrades (AMOLED, payments, and a few extra sensors) are worth $100 more than the 2021-era Forerunner 55, especially now that the 55 sells at a steep discount.
Key Differences
- Screen: The 170 has a bright 1.2-inch AMOLED touchscreen (390 x 390); the 55 uses a smaller 1.04-inch transflective MIP display (208 x 208) that’s dimmer but easier to read in direct sun.
- Payments: The 170 adds Garmin Pay over NFC. The 55 has no contactless payments at all.
- Sensors: The 170 adds SpO2 (blood oxygen), a barometric altimeter, and a compass. The 55 sticks to wrist heart rate and basic motion tracking.
- Battery: The older 55 actually lasts longer in everyday use: 14 days versus 10. GPS battery is a tie at 20 hours.
- Price: The 170 launched at $299.99; the 55 launched at $199.99 and now street-prices well below that.
Deep Dive Comparison
Design & Comfort
Both watches use the same fiber-reinforced polymer build and both carry a 5 ATM water rating, so you can swim or shower with either. The 55 is the lighter of the two at 37 g (42 mm case) versus 41 g (43 mm case) on the 170: a small but real difference on a long run or overnight sleep tracking. The headline gap is the display. The 170’s AMOLED panel is sharper, brighter, and supports touch, which makes scrolling menus and reading mid-run far nicer. The 55’s memory-in-pixel screen is duller and lower-resolution, but it’s always-on by nature and stays legible in harsh sunlight without burning battery.
Battery Life
This is where the “newer is better” story flips. The Forerunner 55 runs about 240… no. It runs 336 hours, or 14 days, in smartwatch mode, while the 170 manages 240 hours, or 10 days. That’s the cost of the AMOLED screen. In GPS tracking mode the two are dead even at 20 hours, which is plenty for any marathon and most ultra distances. If you hate charging gadgets, the older watch quietly wins here.

Health & Fitness Features
Both watches cover the running essentials: wrist-based heart rate, pace, distance, heart-rate zones, recovery time, and Garmin’s training guidance. Both use single-band GPS, and the 55 explicitly pulls from GPS, GLONASS, and Galileo satellites for positioning. The 170 pulls ahead on health depth: it adds SpO2 (blood oxygen) for altitude and sleep insight, plus a barometric altimeter for accurate elevation and stairs climbed, and a compass for heading. The 55 has none of those. For a casual runner chasing pace and mileage, the gap won’t matter. For anyone hiking, training at altitude, or who wants blood oxygen data, the 170 is the clear upgrade.
Smart Features
The 170 supports Garmin Pay through its NFC chip, so you can tap your wrist to pay for water or a post-run coffee. The 55 can’t do that. Both watches push smartphone notifications, and both skip a microphone and speaker, so neither can take calls or run voice commands from your wrist. The 170 carries 4 GB of storage versus the 55’s 32 MB, which mostly buys headroom for activity history and software updates rather than a dramatically different day-to-day experience.
Price & Value
The 170 launched in May 2026 at $299.99, so it’s sitting near full price. The 55 launched back in June 2021 at $199.99 and now routinely discounts to around $150 or less. That widens the real-world gap to roughly $150. The 170 justifies its premium if you value the screen, payments, and extra sensors. But the 55 is one of the best values in running watches precisely because it does the core job for so little. And against the 170, its longer battery is a genuine bonus, not a compromise.
Technical Specs
Spec Garmin Forerunner 170 Garmin Forerunner 55 Released May 2026 June 2021 Weight 41 g 37 g Case Size 43 mm 42 mm Display 1.2-inch AMOLED, 390 x 390 1.04-inch MIP, 208 x 208 Water Rating 5 ATM 5 ATM Battery (Smartwatch) 240 hours (10 days) 336 hours (14 days) Battery (GPS) 20 hours 20 hours GPS Single-band Single-band (GPS/GLONASS/Galileo) NFC Payments Yes (Garmin Pay) No Sensors HR, SpO2, barometric altimeter, compass, gyroscope, accelerometer, thermometer, ambient light HR, accelerometer Storage 4 GB 32 MB Launch Price $299.99 $199.99 The Verdict
For a new buyer, the Forerunner 170 is the watch to get. The AMOLED touchscreen, Garmin Pay, and SpO2 make it feel like a current-generation device, and at $299.99 it’s still affordable for a Garmin. Buy the 170 if you want a modern screen, tap-to-pay, or any health data beyond heart rate.
Buy the Forerunner 55 if you’re price-sensitive or battery-obsessed. At roughly $150 street, it covers the same core running metrics (pace, distance, heart rate, recovery) and it lasts four days longer per charge. It’s the smarter spend for a first running watch on a budget.
Already own a Forerunner 55? Only upgrade if you specifically want the brighter screen, contactless payments, or blood oxygen tracking. If you mainly run and watch your pace, the 55 still does that job and outlasts the 170 between charges. Keep your cash.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Garmin Forerunner should I buy, the 170 or the 55?
For most new buyers, the Forerunner 170 is the pick: the AMOLED screen, Garmin Pay, and SpO2 make it the more modern, more capable watch for about $100 more. Choose the Forerunner 55 if you’re on a tight budget or want the longest battery life, since it handles the same core running metrics for less.
Is the Forerunner 170 worth the upgrade if I already own a Forerunner 55?
Only if you specifically want the brighter AMOLED touchscreen, tap-to-pay, or blood oxygen tracking. If you mostly care about pace, distance, and heart rate, the 55 already nails those and lasts four days longer per charge, so the upgrade isn’t worth it.
Why does the older Forerunner 55 have better battery life?
The 55 uses a low-power transflective MIP display that sips energy, so it runs about 14 days in smartwatch mode versus 10 days on the 170. The 170’s bright AMOLED screen looks far better but costs you those extra days. In GPS mode they’re tied at 20 hours.
Can I make contactless payments on the Forerunner 55?
No. The Forerunner 55 has no NFC chip, so there’s no Garmin Pay support. If tapping your wrist to pay matters to you, you’ll need the Forerunner 170, which adds NFC payments.
Do both watches work with iPhone and Android?
Yes. Both pair with the Garmin Connect app on iOS and Android over Bluetooth, so notifications and syncing work either way. Neither has a microphone or speaker, so you can’t take calls from the watch on either phone.
🏆 Ready to Decide?
Check the latest deals to see which one fits your budget.
Need a broader starting point first? Read Best Fitness Tracker (2026) for the fastest shortlist.
*We earn a commission if you make a purchase.
Specs and features may change. Always verify details on the manufacturer’s official site before purchasing.

